Fairest of Heart - A Snow White Western Romance
Welcome back to Literary Scape, where we explore the wonderful world of historical Christian romance! In this episode, we dove deep into Fairest of Heart, by Karen Witemeyer. A clever Snow White retelling set in the Wild West.
The Story
Fairest of Heart follows Penelope Snow, a young woman whose beauty has been nothing but trouble. Working as a personal maid for a famous actress touring the West, she tries to hide her appearance beneath shapeless dresses. But when circumstances leave her stranded at a ranch with seven old rovers, she catches the attention of Texas Ranger Titus Kingsley—a man who's learned to distrust women after his brother's tragic death.
When Titus is assigned to investigate a robbery case tied to Penelope's acting troupe, all evidence points to her guilt. But perhaps this fairest woman of all truly does have a heart as pure as her last name.
Matching the Seven Rovers to the Dwarfs
One of the most delightful aspects of this retelling is how skillfully the author matched each rover to his fairy tale counterpart:
Sleepy = Angus (always snoring!)
Sneezy = Dusty
Grumpy = Jeb (a fan favorite!)
Doc = The Doctor (Titus’s grandfather.)
Dopey = Rowdy (another fan favorite!)
Happy = Ike
Bashful = Coy (the name says it all!)
And let's not forget Rowdy, who filled a special role in the story with his wandering that proved so crucial to finding Penelope.
What We Loved
The hosts were impressed by how faithfully the author stuck to the original Snow White story while seamlessly weaving it into a Western setting. From Penelope cleaning and cooking for the rovers to the way Narcissa (the evil queen figure) treated Cecil as her huntsman, every element felt both familiar and fresh.
Favorite Characters:
Jeb (Grumpy) stole hearts with his gruff exterior that softened around Penelope—especially in that memorable knife scene where he teaches her proper self-defense!
Rowdy was universally beloved for his childlike innocence and crucial role in the story
The rovers as a group brought warmth and humor throughout
The Romance & Faith Elements
True to the fairy tale source, this is a sweet, innocent romance. The romantic tension builds beautifully, but the physical romance stays at an espresso level—just a hint, with the payoff coming at the very end.
The inspirational elements shine through Penelope's unwavering faith during impossible circumstances, constantly reminding herself that "God brought me this far, He's not going to abandon me now." This persevering faith earned the book a mocha to latte rating for inspirational content.
Our Ratings Breakdown
Using our signature coffee scale (espresso = a little, mocha = medium, latte = a lot):
Romance Level: Espresso (sweet and innocent)
Suspense Level: Mocha (plenty of "what happens next?" moments)
Mystery Level: Mocha (surprising how much mystery fit into a familiar story!)
Inspirational Level: Mocha to Latte (strong faith themes throughout)
Drama Level: Espresso (kept drama light, true to fairy tale style)
Overall Lasso Rating: 2 to 2.5 out of 3
Final Thoughts
Fairest of Heart by Karen Witemeyer proves that familiar stories can find new life in skilled hands. While knowing the Snow White story might make some plot points predictable, the Western setting and well-developed characters keep readers engaged. This is a solid, enjoyable read that successfully bridges the gap between beloved fairy tale and historical Christian romance.
Karen Witemeyer's ability to transform these classic stories into cowboy romances is truly impressive—and we can't wait to discuss next week's episode featuring If the Boot Fits, a Cinderella retelling!
Have you read Fairest of Heart? We'd love to hear your thoughts! And don't forget to sign up for our newsletter at literaryscape.com/newsletter for updates on upcoming episodes and events for both readers and authors.
Coming Up Next Week: If the Boot Fits - A Cinderella Western Romance
Until next time, happy and blessed reading and writing!
